Both doctor appointment And doctor appointment acceptable to describe a medical visit. In the first case the ‘S, instead of showing ownership, actually shows association; Appointments of this nature are linked to the doctor. In the following case, the noun doctor being used adjective to describe the type of appointment.
Grammar, self-healing.
Let’s say you’re due for an annual health check. You say you have a “doctor appointment” or a “doctor appointment”?
If you’re like most English speakers, you’d say “doctor appointment,” although there’s nothing wrong with the less common “doctor appointment.”
Why do most of us say “doctor’s appointment”? The simple answer is that it’s convention. The reason why either is good is more complicated — so read on, language geek.
Whose date is it?
The most popular function of ‘S in English is to show possession, as in “the cat’s bowl.” There are other ways to show possession—like “cat’s bowl”—but ‘S is the way it is most commonly done.
But that’s not all ‘S do. Although we recognize that such statements are deeply controversial, ‘S sometimes a sign of the plural, as in “mind your p’s and q’s” and “a pattern of x’s.” It also acts as a contract form of we IN let’s and form of contract To be like its, She isAnd he is.
But also ‘S looks like a common possession sign at first glance but it’s actually something else. Let’s move on to the phrase “meowing cat”. It’s not really the meow that belongs to the cat but the meow that comes from the cat. The ‘S in “the cat’s meow” the mark is not possessive (in the strict sense of the word) but genitive, and specifically what we might call genitive of origin.
Hereditary case
“Ah, of course, possessively,” said almost no one. We will explain: possessive manner is a grammatical case (quick review: a grammatical case is, a category of clear semantic relations in the various forms that a noun, pronoun or adjective has) shows that someone or something owns, controls or is associated with someone or something else.
The possessive case is very similar to the possessive case. In fact, when people talk about the possessive case in modern English, they mostly call it the possessive case. (This is largely due to a very influential 18th-century grammarian, Bishop Lowth, who thought “possessive case” was the better term.) own, in some cases it muddies the semantic waters. For our purposes, we’ll stick with hereditary caseeasier to understand than in terms of control and association as well as ownership.
There are several types in the genitive case, among them is the “possitive origin”, which we see in the “cat purr”. Another is the “possessive description”, which is exactly how Patricia T. O’Conner and Stewart Kellerman define “doctor’s appointment” on their excellent Grammarphobia blog. The authors describe this pair of phrases:
In the phrase “doctor appointment” the noun “doctor” is being used exclusively to describe the type of appointment, while in “doctor appointment” the noun is being used according to attribution (i.e. adjective) to do the same thing.
The term “doctor” in the first example is often called “descriptive possessive” and “doctor” in the second example is “attributive noun”, “auxiliary noun” or “pre-modifier”. noun”.
There aren’t any hard and fast rules about using a noun genetically or attributively as a modifier before another noun. However, some usages are more idiomatic (i.e. natural to native speakers) than others.
Our research concurs: both “appointment with doctor” and “appointment with doctor” are syntactically and grammatically correct. Why “doctor appointment” is the more popular choice since any form doctor start editing appointment with any rule (which until the second part of the 20th century) can be nothing more than convention.
Categories: Usage Notes
Source: vothisaucamau.edu.vn
